Do You Think You’re Good?
Today was the first day of spring semester. In my adaptation class, we were going around doing introductions of ourselves: names, where you’re from, what you write, why you’re in the program, etc. When it was my term I gave the basic schpeel.
When I was done the professor remarked, “I noticed you said something interesting. You said you thought you were good. What makes you think that?” My immediate was to blush and think to myself, ‘oh, shit, did I say that? Did I seem like a cocky asshole?’
I stammered out that I’d had some moderate success in the last year or two, optioning a screenplay and placing in a prestigious competition. I was really embarrassed and wanted her to move on to the next person. But she lingered, saying, “This town is littered with people who optioned a screenplay or placed in a competition. There’s a difference between winning competitions and being good. Don’t confuse the two.”
I turned even more red and tried to mumble something inane that wouldn’t make the situation any worse; I was racking my brain trying to remember exactly what I said. I finally remembered:
I was describing how I got into screenwriting. I believe I said something to the extent of, “I moved to LA in 2005, shortly after graduating from Dartmouth, with the goal of being a film director. An agent and friend recommended writing as a good way to get into directing, so I decided to write a screenplay. I really enjoyed it and realized I was pretty good at it, so I pursued it.” Etc, etc…
When I look at it that way, it doesn’t sound that bad. But the way it was presented in class, I felt like I had said the worst thing ever. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized, I do think I’m a good screenwriter. That’s part of the reason I enjoy it, and why I’m pursing it as a career. I don’t think I’m the best, or even great (yet) but I do think I’m good. That doesn’t mean I don’t have room for improvement, or that I’m stuck up, it just means I have a healthy self confidence (well, in terms of writing, at least) and an awareness of my own abilities. So why, if it’s the truth, did I feel so ashamed when my professor brought it up?
When I got home, I asked my roommate, Jeff, and our friend, Eric, both of whom are artists in their own mediums (acting/costume design and music/writing respectively,) if they would ever say they were “good” at their art. Both replied that they would be mortified to do so. We talked about it for a while, and it seems that it’s pretty unilaterally accepted across artistic fields that you can’t admit to your own abilities. It’s not just about being humble, but you have to actively think you suck, otherwise you cross the line from artist to cocky hack.
I can’t imagine a lawyer (or doctor, teacher, construction worker, computer programmer, etc) being too embarrassed to say they were good at their job. I’m not saying they go about bragging about their proven superiority, but most of these people would be able to honestly tell you if they thought they were good at their jobs, and no one would think anything else of it.
So why do us artsy kids get so hot and bothered about it? Why are we expected to be self loathing and incapable of realistic self evaluation? There’s this stigma that you can’t ever be satisfied with your creative work, because if you are you won’t try to improve. That just seems horribly depressing to me. I can look back and see the flaws in my work - probably more than most other people can - but I can also tell you which pieces I think are successful and which aren’t and why. And I will try to make something even better next time around. I don’t want to feel like to be a respected writer I have to constantly be hating on myself (I do that enough in other arenas of my life.)
I am a good writer. I’m proud of that. I hope to keep working so one day I can be a great writer.
So why then, even in this blog post, does it make me so ashamed to say so?